Thursday, August 14, 2008

Proposal: The Truly Modern Pentathlon

The 'modern pentathlon' is an idealized version of the efforts of a cavalry soldier caught behind enemy lines. Shooting, swordplay, swimming, riding an unfamiliar horse, and running. (My thanks to LawDog for his discussion of it; I'll be keeping an eye out for it next week.)

There's only one problem with it: nobody uses horses anymore. 'Cavalry' means tanks now, or even helicopters. (Nobody uses swords, either.)

But let's take the concept of cavalry, and extend it forward - an elite strike force whose job is to shock the enemy with their sudden blow and then get away before they can retaliate. Sounds like a fighter or fighter-bomber pilot. So let's create the truly modern pentathlon:
  • Fighter combat sim. Plenty of them available. Networked for head-to-head combat, round-robin or pool play or what have you.
  • Shooting. Service pistol would be best, although they'd probably do the same wimpy air gun as now.
  • Orienteering. Here's a map and a compass. Fastest person to reach all the checkpoints wins.
  • Swimming.
  • Running. (As opposed to orienteering; this time, you've got a set course.)
I'd pondered skydiving instead of orienteering, but the problem is that it's hard to make it competitive without it becoming an advanced gymnastics contest. Given that the goal of an ejecting fighter pilot is to make it down in one piece, that didn't seem like a good fit.

Anyway, treat it like you do now - score each part, use that to determine when everybody starts for the final run.

1 comment:

perlhaqr said...

To keep it more in line with the original idea, make the first event a driving course in a northeast African style Technical.

I'm also thinking that combining the orienteering, running, and shooting practicals into a "find your way to this location, assault the target, as quickly as possible" event would be cool, but it does tend to kill the "pentathlon" idea.